I needed a DI box that is rugged enough to bring on gigs/tours and with good enough sound quality for recording. I also needed something (relatively) cheap, that I won't mind leaving on a stage floor, where it can get easily stolen. Low noise and good handling of dynamics/peaks was also a key deciding factor.
I already own several more "hi-end" DI-boxes from various manufacturers (ZOD, Radial JDV, Rupert Neve, TAB Funkenwerk). These are all more studio oriented and for various reasons not very suitable for a life on the road. Most of them are too large/bulky, and with the exception of the Neve they all need a seperate power cable. Some of them are also tube DIs, and from experience I don't want anything with tubes thrown around a stage floor. The Neve is the only of these that has the functionality and form factor that I'm looking for, but personally I find it too expensive to leave it unguarded on a stage floor.
The only two DI boxes I already own that are (in my opinion) suitable for live gigs are the JDI and J48 from Radial. Unfortunately these have some disadvantages. I mainly play passive basses, so the passive JDI isn't ideal for live gigs with potentially long cable runs. For recording I love the tone of the JDI, even with passive basses, but from experience I won't risk using it for live gigs. The J48 (active) would seem like a better choice for my needs, but unfortunately it noticeable darkens the tone a bit. I have seen other reports about this too. Apparently this is caused by the rather low input impedance of the J48. The darkening is most noticeable in the signal going to the amp. So while the J48 is a very good choice if I only use a DI (where a slight darkening of the tone is probably a good thing) I don't like the J48 when combining DI+amp. The tone coming out of the amp loses too much clarity and definition.
So, I needed something different for live gigs. 95% of the time, DI boxes are provided by the venue, but from experience I have found it necessary to always bring a spare. For this purpose I needed a small, compact DI box that can fit inside a guitar case/bag, can be powered by phantom power and has excellent tone/dynamics and low noise. I also don't want anything crazy expensive.
I had already used this model from BSS on countless occasions, because it is more or less the standard choice at venues and PA/backline-companies in my part of the world. I already knew it would be a excellent choice for live gigs.
I had never used the BSS for recordings though. Like I mentioned above, I already have a nice selection of hi-end DI boxes in my studio, but for remote recordings I have been using the smaller, more convenient Radial models mentioned above.
So, I made some quick recordings for comparison. While this BSS wasn't tonally quite up there with my most expensive studio DIs, it didn't stand out as particularly bad either. We're talking about rather subtle differences here. Compared to the Radial J48, I could have gone either way when ONLY using a DI, but I much preferred the tone of the BSS when combining DI+amp. The BSS does not suffer from the darkening of the tone that I get with the J48.
As for noise issues, the BSS is as good or better than all the DI boxes mentioned above, and considerably better than some cheaper options I've tested.
Another problem with cheaper DI boxes is that the dynamics can come across as a bit "clacky". This is not an issue at all with the BSS (or with any of the other DI boxes mentioned above).
To sum it up:
This BSS DI-box is:
-A very good DI box for the money. Personally I wouldn't even consider any cheaper options than this. Cheap DI-boxes usually suffer from noise issues and poor handling of dynamics/peaks.
-Excellent for live gigs, my personal first choice!
-A very convenient DI box for remote recordings, with more than adequate sound quality.
-Not quite as good as more expensive "hi-end" DI boxes (costing ten times as much!) for regular studio recordings, but still good enough that I wouldn't at all mind using the BSS it was the only available option.
If you're looking for a reasonably price DI-box, don't go any cheaper than this. Unless you want to spend at least 3-4 times as much (or more!) THIS is the one to get.